Should You Replace a Lost Key or Rekey a Lock?

January 31, 2025

Losing a key can be a frustrating experience, leaving you worried about security risks and access issues. When faced with this situation, you generally have two options: replace the lost key or rekey the lock. While both solutions offer security and convenience, understanding their implications can help you make the right choice. In this guide, we’ll break down each option, discussing when one is preferable over the other, the risks involved, and expert recommendations to ensure your home or business remains secure.


5 Reasons Why Rekeying is Better Than Replacing Your Locks


Understanding Key Replacement

What Does Key Replacement Involve?

Key replacement is a straightforward process that involves creating a duplicate key for your existing lock. This method is ideal if you have a spare key or can access a locksmith who can cut a new key based on the lock model.

When Should You Replace a Lost Key?

If you’re confident that your lost key isn’t in the wrong hands or that it was misplaced within a secure location, a simple key replacement might be the best option. For example, if you lost your key inside your home or office and are sure it hasn’t been stolen, replacing it will save you both time and money.

Potential Risks of Replacing a Lost Key

The biggest risk with replacing a lost key is the possibility that someone else may find and use it. If your key was lost in a public place or near your property, someone with bad intentions could gain access. In such cases, replacing the key alone may not be enough to secure your property.


Understanding Rekeying

What Does Rekeying Involve?

Rekeying is a process where the lock mechanism is adjusted to work with a new key, rendering the old key useless. A locksmith will change the pins inside the lock cylinder, ensuring that only a new key can operate the lock.

When Should You Rekey a Lock?

Rekeying is the safer option if there is any doubt about the security of your lost key. If you suspect the key was stolen or lost in an area where someone could trace it back to your home or office, rekeying eliminates the risk of unauthorized access. Additionally, if you’ve moved into a new home or office, rekeying is a wise precaution to ensure former occupants or workers no longer have access.

Potential Risks of Rekeying

Rekeying does not replace the entire lock; it simply changes the internal mechanism. If your lock is old or damaged, rekeying may not be the best option, as the lock itself might still be vulnerable to break-ins. In such cases, a complete lock replacement may be a better long-term solution.


Cost Comparison: Key Replacement vs. Rekeying

Which Option Is More Affordable?

In general, replacing a lost key is the most cost-effective option, especially if you already have a spare. However, rekeying is also relatively affordable compared to replacing the entire lock. The cost of rekeying varies based on the type of lock and the locksmith’s service fees but is often a worthwhile investment for added security.


Expert Recommendations: What Should You Do?

  1. Assess the Risk: If you believe your key was stolen or lost in an insecure location, rekeying is the best option.
  2. Consider Convenience: If you have a spare key or the lost key was misplaced within a secure area, replacing the key might be enough.
  3. Think Long-Term: If your lock is old or outdated, replacing it entirely might be a better investment for enhanced security.
  4. Consult a Locksmith: A professional locksmith can assess your specific situation and recommend the most secure and cost-effective solution.


Preventive Measures to Avoid Future Issues

  • Have Spare Keys: Always keep a duplicate key in a safe place to avoid being locked out.
  • Use a Key Finder: Modern Bluetooth key finders can help you track your keys to avoid losing them in the first place.
  • Upgrade to Smart Locks: If you frequently lose keys, consider installing a smart lock system that uses codes or biometrics for entry.


Conclusion

Deciding whether to replace a lost key or rekey a lock depends on the circumstances surrounding the loss. If security is a concern, rekeying is the safest option. If you’re certain your key is merely misplaced and won’t be found by the wrong person, a key replacement may suffice. Always assess the risks involved and, when in doubt, consult a professional locksmith to ensure your home or business remains secure.

Call Us Any Time!

Call Now
By Youmna Rehman November 26, 2025
Can a locksmith upgrade your car’s OEM key system? Absolutely. Learn how automotive locksmiths enhance security, program smart keys, add remote start, and modernize outdated vehicle key systems—often faster and cheaper than dealerships.
By Ghulam Mustafa November 26, 2025
Protect your home from vandalism and forced entry with smart, out-of-the-box lock security strategies. Learn practical, affordable, and legal ways to deter intruders, strengthen your doors, and safeguard your locks beyond the usual advice.
By Ghulam Mustafa November 25, 2025
Learn what to do when your smart lock software is no longer supported, the security risks involved, how to maintain access, and when to upgrade. A complete guide to keeping your home safe with or without manufacturer updates.
By Ghulam Mustafa November 25, 2025
Learn whether a locksmith can install locks on glass or frameless doors, what types of locks work best, how installation is done without damaging the glass, and why professional expertise is essential for secure, safe results.
By Youmna Rehman November 23, 2025
Learn how to secure exterior gates, fences, and garden doors with durable locks, stronger materials, better lighting, and smart security upgrades. Protect your home’s weakest entry points with expert tips and locksmith-backed strategies.
By Ghulam Mustafa November 22, 2025
Discover what really happens when a smart lock’s firmware update fails, why it occurs, the risks involved, and how to safely recover or reset the lock without damaging your door. Perfect guide for homeowners using smart security.
By Youmna Rehman November 22, 2025
Learn how to choose the best locks for modular or prefabricated homes, including smart options, weather resistance, installation factors, and security tips for factory-built structures.
By Youmna Rehman November 19, 2025
Discover whether smart locks are safe for elderly users or individuals with accessibility needs. Learn about benefits, risks, essential features, and how to choose the right lock for comfort, independence, and security. Great for caregivers and families.
More Posts